Is it cheaper living on a cruise than it is on land?


Many cruise fans joke that they just about live on the water – but would you consider doing just that? With house prices and cost of living the major cities increasing, Cruise&Travel Asia has done a comparison between living at sea vs living on land. While the idea has only been pioneered by retirees, we stack up the figures.

Dollars and sense

If money is no object, permanent residence vessels such as The World or The Utopia beckon, with their no-holds-barred luxury on-board homes that tip seven or even eight figures to buy – and then require up to 10 per cent of the price in ongoing annual fees.

Crystal Cruises caused a sizable buzz last year when it announced its new and reportedly more affordable Residences at Sea. These 48 customisable apartments will be spread across three of their fleet, to launch no later than 2018. However, these have been aimed at the upper end of the market, too, for those looking for a second or holiday home, rather than a primary place of residence.

According to the DBS-Manulife Retirement Wellness Study, which was conducted in November 2015, Singaporeans need around SGD$1,200 a month for entertainment, food, utility and phone bills as well as public transportation, but doesn’t factor in medical expenses or retirement care. That averages out to cost around SGD$40 a day. Of course, for these starting prices, a retiree would be looking at basic retirement accommodations that cannot compare to a cruising lifestyle. In comparison, the daily cost of living at sea might be about AUD$123 on Carnival, or AUD$193 on one of Princess’s world cruises, based on twin share and depending on your cabin choice – and whether you can negotiate a discount. For argument’s sake, that works out at an annual starting cost of around AUD$45,000 to live on a ship for a year, if there were no on-shore stays.

Making it happen

If you are ready to embrace the sea life for retirement, there are several ways to keep costs down. A good cruise agent can help narrow down suitable ships and cruise lines, especially focusing on those offering discounts for long bookings, early bookings and for seniors, naturally. Princess is the only cruise line to offer world cruises from Australia,  while Cunard and P&O U.K. also offer lengthy world cruises. Seabourn offers discounts for frequent cruisers and those who combine voyages, with a 15 per cent saving on combined cruises.

With enough notice, an agent can also negotiate on your behalf for the best possible price, and even for such privileges as bringing on board your favourite comfy chair.

For those unafraid of a few logistical adventures, chasing the sales from ship to ship rather than staying on the one vessel lets you take advantage of low-season fares, two-for-one deals and so on. However, you will need to build in the costs of transfers and accommodation arrangements between cruises.

Even those wanting to settle on the one ship will need a ‘landing pad’ of some sort for when the ship is at port, receiving maintenance and having other passenger-free days. Rather than eschewing a home on land altogether, it may work better to switch a larger home for a basic apartment or pied-à-terre in your home port, depending on ongoing costs.

What if?

Speaking of logistics, a retirement at sea brings with it great distances: distance from family and friends, from your mail and banks, and importantly, from medical specialists. While so many vessels now carry state-of-the-art medical teams and equipment, it is always possible that a medical emergency will bring with it a logistical (and expensive) nightmare, with helicopter airlifts, foreign hospitals and insurance headaches.

Some of the very big advantages, however, combine the best of cruising with the best of retirement: 24-hour room service, and a constant holiday atmosphere that could never compare with that of a retirement home, along with a somewhat privileged standing with the crew and a regular turnover of potential friends boarding the ship, every embarkation.  The constant change in scenery is something a retirement home could never rival.